The Grinch who ruined Christmas has a reason for being so bitter of life growing up. As a child, he was picked on for being green and having hair all over his body and a beard. Show me the child who would not pick on such a classmate and I will show you Baby Jesus. But if “Dr. Seuss’ How the Grinch Stole Christmas” had only worked on that angle some more, had drummed up a little more sympathy for the Grinch, maybe we wouldn’t want to pick on him too.
This is a movie that devotes enormous resources to the mistaken belief that children and their parents want to see a dank, eerie, weird movie about a sour creature who lives on top of a mountain of garbage, scares children, is mean to his dog, and steals everyone’s Christmas presents. Yes, How the Grinch Stole Christmas film has a happy ending, and even a saintly little girl who believes the Grinch is not that all bad, but there’s not much happiness before the ending, and the little girl is more of a plot device than a character.
The Grinch is portrayed by the one and only Jim Carrey, who works as hard as an actor has ever worked in a film, to small avail. He leaps, he tumbles, he contorts, he sneers, he grimaces, he taunts, he flies through the air and tunnels through the garbage mountain, he gets stuck in chimneys and blown up in explosions, and all the time. . . .
Well, he’s not Jim Carrey. After John Travolta and Robin Williams were paid tons of millions to feature inside unrecognizable makeup in “Battlefield Earth” and “Bicentennial Man,” respectively, did it seem to anyone that when viewers go to a film with a big star, they buy their tickets in the hopes of being able to see that star? Jim Carrey has hidden behind invented masks before, in “The Mask,” for instance, but his Grinch, with his pig-snout nose and Mr. Hyde hairstyle, looks more like a perverse wolfman than the hero of a comedy.
The movie uses gigantic sets, lots of special effects and trick photography to create Whoville, which is inside a snowflake, and where all the Whos live in merry jollity, preparing for Christmas. The Grinch resides in a cave on the mountain of garbage that towers over the town, brooding and gnashing and recalling old wounds and childhood bad memories. Eventually the happiness below is so unbearable to him that he descends on the town and steals all the Christmas presents, and only the touching faith of little Cindy Lou Who (Taylor Momsen) redeems him.
But the general outlines of the story, expanded here, will be familiar from Dr. Seuss’ book. What is strange is how the inspiration of his drawings has been expanded almost grotesquely into a world so unattractive and menacing. Red is the dominant color in the palate–not Santa red, but a kind of grungy, brownish red, so much of it we yearn to slake our eyes on green or blue. The picture appears to have been shot through a subtle filter that just slightly blurs everything, and the result is not so delightful. All of the characters, as I have mentioned, have noses that look like atrophied upturned pig snouts, which is nice if you like atrophied upturned pig snouts, but not if you don’t.
The balance is off. There should be more sequences showing sympathy for the Grinch, fewer shots establishing his meanness, more takes to make the townspeople look interesting, a jollier production design and a brighter look overall. I am not a mind-reader and cannot be sure, but I think a lot of children are going to look at this movie with perplexity and distaste. It’s just not much fun. Grownups may appreciate Carrey’s incredible performance in an intellectual kind of way and give him points for what was obviously a supreme effort, but the storyline doesn’t give the Grinch any help. Of course, I may be wrong. As the Grinch himself observes, “One man’s toxic sludge is another man’s potpourri.” Or vice versa, I’m afraid.